Andrew Hurrell • June 19, 2025

What Makes a Poor Website? 🚫 The Costly Mistakes That Drive Customers Away

Your website should work for your business, not against it

What makes a poor website the costly mistakes that drive customers away

We've all been there – you click on a website link, wait for what feels like an eternity for it to load, then struggle to find what you're looking for before giving up in frustration. 😤


As a business owner, the last thing you want is for potential customers to have this experience with your website.


Your website is often the first impression people get of your business, yet so many companies unknowingly sabotage their own success with poor web design choices.


Let's explore the most common website mistakes that could be costing you customers – and more importantly, how to avoid them.

Slow Loading Times ⏰


Nothing kills a first impression faster than a website that takes forever to load. In today's fast-paced world, people expect websites to load within 2-3 seconds maximum.


If your site takes longer than that, you're likely losing potential customers before they even see what you offer.


Common culprits include oversized images, too many plugins, cheap hosting, and bloated code.


Think of your website like a shop front – if customers had to wait five minutes for your door to open, they'd walk away and visit your competitor instead.

Confusing Navigation 🧭


A poor website often feels like a maze with no clear path to the exit.


When visitors can't easily find what they're looking for, they'll abandon ship faster than you can say "contact us."


Your navigation should be intuitive and logical.


If someone lands on your homepage, they should be able to find your services, pricing, and contact information within one to two clicks. 


Avoid fancy menu names that sound clever but confuse visitors – stick to clear, descriptive labels that everyone understands.

Mobile Unfriendly Design 📱


With over 60% of web traffic now coming from mobile devices, having a website that doesn't work properly on phones and tablets is business suicide.


A poor website either doesn't display correctly on mobile or requires users to pinch and zoom to read the content.


Mobile-unfriendly sites don't just frustrate users – Google actively penalises them in search results.


If your website isn't responsive, you're not just losing visitors; you're losing visibility in search engines too.


Outdated Design and Content 📅

Nothing screams "unprofessional" like a website that looks like it was built in 2005.


Outdated design elements, old colour schemes, and ancient stock photos make your business appear behind the times.


Equally damaging is outdated content.


If your latest news post is from 2019 or your team photos show people who left years ago, visitors will question whether your business is still operating. 


Fresh, current content shows you're active and engaged with your customers.

A man is pulling a speedometer with a rope.

Poor Contact Information 📞


One of the biggest website sins is making it difficult for customers to get in touch with you. 


Burying your contact details in a hard-to-find corner, providing only a generic contact form, or worse – having incorrect phone numbers or addresses – creates unnecessary barriers between you and potential customers.


Your contact information should be prominently displayed on every page, preferably in the header or footer.


Include multiple ways to reach you: phone, email, and physical address if relevant to your business.


Overwhelming or Cluttered Layout 🎨

A poor website often tries to cram everything onto one page, creating a chaotic mess that overwhelms visitors.


Too many colours, fonts, images, and competing elements make it impossible for users to focus on what's important.


Good web design follows the principle of "less is more." White space is your friend – it helps guide the eye and makes your content more digestible.


Focus on one clear message per page and use visual hierarchy to guide visitors through your content.

A screenshot of a website for Aspen Home Improvements

Lack of Clear Call-to-Actions 📢


Many websites fail because they don't tell visitors what to do next.


Without clear call-to-action buttons or instructions, potential customers might browse your site but never take the next step to contact you or make a purchase.


Every page should have a clear purpose and guide visitors towards a specific action, whether that's calling you, filling out a form, booking an appointment, or requesting a quote.


Make these actions obvious and easy to complete.


No Social Proof or Testimonials ⭐

People trust other people's opinions more than marketing messages.


A website without customer testimonials, reviews, or case studies misses a crucial opportunity to build trust and credibility.


Social proof doesn't just mean testimonials:


It can include client logos, awards, certifications, or even simple statements about how long you've been in business.


These elements can help your visitors feel confident about choosing you and your services.


A green stamp with a red ribbon that says social proof.

Technical Issues and Broken Links 🔧


Not sure if you're aware but nothing undermines professionalism like a broken link, or an error message, or even forms that don't work properly.


These issues make visitors question your reliability and lack of attention to detail.


Regular website maintenance is essential. Check your links regularly, we suggest monthly, test your contact forms, and ensure all features work as expected.


A well-maintained website reflects a well-run business.


The Bottom Line 💡


Your website should work for your business, not against it.


While fixing these issues might seem daunting, remember that even small improvements can make a big difference to your customer's journey and, ultimately, your bottom line.


The good news? 


Most of these problems are completely fixable with the right approach and expertise.


Whether you tackle them yourself or work with a professional, addressing these common issues will help ensure your website becomes a powerful tool for growing your business rather than a barrier to success.


Remember, your website is working 24/7 to represent your business – make sure it's putting your best foot forward! 🚀


Feeling Overwhelmed?


I understand - SEO can seem like a full-time job. That's why we offer Local Business Visibility Packages to fit all budgets.


We'll manage your entire Google Business Profile, local SEO, and review management while you concentrate on what you do best - running your business.


But before anything else, let’s see where you stand.


Grab your free 15-minute Local Visibility Boost Session


No pressure, no sales pitch - just real, actionable tips tailored to your business.

Book Visibility Boost Session Call

Want more tips like these?



Pop your email in below for our Quick Tips Tuesday newsletter. No faff, just practical advice you can use straight away.

Why Every Small Business Needs a Website: Your Digital Shopfront That Never Closes ?
By Andrew Hurrell June 12, 2025
Discover why every UK small business needs a website in 2025. From 24/7 customer access to local SEO benefits - get found online and beat competitors today!
The Hidden Heroes of Your Website: Why Meta Titles and Descriptions Matter More Than You Think ?
By Andrew Hurrell June 2, 2025
Discover why meta titles and descriptions are crucial for your business. Learn how to write compelling SEO elements that boost clicks and customers.
Unlocking the Power of Email Marketing: 5 Strategies Small Businesses Can Implement Today
By Andrew Hurrell May 27, 2025
Discover 5 actionable email marketing strategies that deliver £42 for every £1 spent. Build quality lists, segment audiences, and create compelling campaigns that convert.
What is Local SEO and How Does It Work
By Andrew Hurrell May 20, 2025
Discover what Local SEO is and how it works to boost your business visibility in local searches. Learn practical strategies to outrank competitors and attract nearby customers.
DIY Website Builders: The Hidden Costs Behind That 'Easy' Website Solution
By Andrew Hurrell April 30, 2025
Thinking of using Wix or other DIY website builders? Discover the hidden costs and SEO challenges that could be costing your UK business thousands in lost opportunities. 🔍"
The Tiny Icon That Makes a Mighty Impact: Why Your Website Needs a Favicon ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 24, 2025
Learn why adding a favicon to your website can boost trust, brand visibility, and user experience - one tiny icon, big results! A favicon (short for 'favourite icon') .
Why Your Website Might Be Driving Customers Away (And How to Fix It!) ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 17, 2025
Discover real-world fixes to stop your website driving customers away! From the '3-Second Rule' to the 'Gran Test', learn practical improvements that actually work for UK businesses. No waffle, just results. 🚀
Why Your Marketing Isn't Working (And What I Learned From My Friend) ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 10, 2025
Discover why fancy marketing language might be hurting your business. Learn from a real marketer's mistake and get tips to make you more authentic & effective.
Marketing Chat From My Desk ?
By Andrew Hurrell April 2, 2025
Website not ranking! Do yourself a favour. Get your nan to read your website. If she don't get it, bin it. Talk like a person not a robot!
The £50 Marketing Trick That Saved A Local Chippy
By Andrew Hurrell March 26, 2025
Discover how a local chip shop owner used a £50 marketing trick to win back customers and boost business. A story about authentic content beating big competition.
More From The Vault